I can't get any sort of read on Claymore as his behavior is too freaking erratic, but my gut tells me that he's not Mafia and my gut is a completely valid source. He seems useful to have around as they keep people off balance as developing a strategy to deal with him is difficult as his approaches always changes.
That brings me to Lopez. Lopez always looks suspicious. He rolefished in Simplicity Mafia and seemingly accuses people on a whim but doesn't change his vote as often as someone like Xeras and his overall strategy doesn't seem as variable. Maybe it's just his play style, but one of these games he will be Mafia and will have the reasoning of "I always look suspicious; it's just how I roll" to back him up. Maybe that's this game. It's D1 and there's little to go off, so he seems as good a choice as anyone else, so...Vote: Lopez
DarkClaymore - 4 (SjSharks, DisgaeaBlitz, Bloo, Xeras)
Quillbell - 2 (Lopez, Jericho)
Lopez - 3 (Aphrah, DarkClaymore, Necro)
Xeras - 2 (Shizuka, Mizu)
Necrofantasia - 1 (Nazou)
Lopez, if you go down and are Town, I'm genuinely sorry that I participated in continuing your tradition of bowing out early in these games. I think the farthest you've made it since I started playing was Night 2 in the murder mystery one. You're getting close to the level of "permanent Mafia Madden cover athlete