LAMV wrote:I mean, some things in the show disappointed me, too, but I don't quite have the time or motivation to create a dozen page essay about it. I just think you guys seemed a little *too* upset.
If you like something, you want to talk about it. :U Doesn't seem that odd to me, and that really wasn't that long anyway.
BleachBummer wrote:I'm not, I personally find the series to have a great end. I just want all this talk about how some people hate the ending. I mean, would you rather have Madoka become a witch again for the third time and Homura doesn't go back in time this time so everyone dies like they did in "The End of Evangelion"? Because that is the impression I am getting here with these people's complaints.
There are a variety of options. There's the "Madoka doesn't become a PM at all", there's the "Homura dies and we don't get to see what happens", there's "it ends with Homura looping again", there's "Homura dies, Madoka becomes meguka, defeats Walpurgis, and the cycle continues" and various variations thereof, and so on. There are really COUNTLESS things that could have been done that just make more sense than the trashy mess that was thrown at us. There's even the "Homura becomes a witch and Madoka must fight her" conclusion, which I never even considered until now, just more the much more obvious "Homura's witch form was Walpurgis Night all along".
I've never even touched Eva, surprisingly, but all in all, I'll still say that Madoka did a bad job with the ending.