Mafia General Discussion

[PringlesXD]

15) JerichoDeath
16) Necrofantasia
17) MizuMikomi
18) Xeras
19) ShadowJetX
20) Redhorse
21) DarkClaymore
22) vampko
23) raspberrylicious
24) PringlesXD

Adding my name to the queue because I'm sexy ~ ♥

[Shizuka]

I know I'll win the award "Cursed by Random.org to be mafia all the time".

[darkclaymore]

I know I'll win the award "Cursed by Random.org to be mafia all the time".

It'd be a tough competition as apparently you're not the only one to fit this category (Redhorse comes to mind when I think of others).



And while people seem to avoid voting for whatever reason, I'll use this thread to get opinion on something rather random and, perhaps, pointless. Still, a subject that interests me personally.

I already made all the banners for my next game and wonder whatever they surpass my previous ones.

Episode 1:





Episode 2:






Opinion?

[PringlesXD]

They're a lot better, gratz ~

[MizuMikomi]

Best Mod - Necro
Best Player - DarkClaymore
Favorite Player - Xeras

Best Flavor - Mafia X: Paradigm Shift
Best Scenes - Mafia IX: An Unknown World Jericho's scenes were great.
Best Setup - Mafia 8: Imperishable Night - It worked out the best of all others.
Best Mechanic - Choose your role Mafia - Choosing your own role. Need I say more?
Most Enjoyable Game - Mafia X: Paradigm Shift - It was fun, and I liked the concept. Experimentation is always a good thing IMO
Best Game - Mafia 8: Imperishable Night - I only watched but it turned out the best IMO.

Now with that out of the way...
They look great, Claymore, a lot better this time ~

GIMP crashed while I was working on one of mine, so I'll have to try again... oh joy... >_>

[raspberrylicious]

I'm not gonna vote, as I haven't been here for every game!

Time to wait for mafia awards 2012?

[Xeras]

Best Mod - Necrofantasia - I really like his games. I look up to him when it comes to making games, with balance, and flavor in mind. In my opinion his games are the ones that should set the bar.

Best Player - Sj - I am always happy when I stop his plans. His silver tongue make him fun to play against as well.
Favorite Player - Claymore - I love talking strategy with him. I cannot wait until he is done with his military thing. B-but it's not because I love him or anything.

Best Flavor - Vampko's Slice of Life. At first, I was skeptical about how the flips would work... but after seeing it in motion it was good. Also, the mechanic with delayed abilities was awesome as well.
Best Scenes - Jericho's Game. It had a lot of creativity there. <3
Best Setup - Vampko's first game. The unexpected chaos was great.
Best Mechanic - As far as the mechanics, it was pretty good.
Most Enjoyable Game - Vampko's first game. The fact that I was able to actually claim my role, and people still having no idea what I was, was great. Also, the manipulation of night actions were cool too. Though, I didn't mean to mess with the cop. ^^'
Best Game - Mafia 8: Imperishable Night -Even if I did get bussed from the beginning. xD

[lopez]

Best Mod - SJ, I suppose.
Best Player - N/A
Favorite Player - N/A
Best Flavor -
Best Scenes - Nothing really comes to mind.
Best Setup - Mafia 1, simple and effective.
Best Mechanic - Nothing comes to mind.
Most Enjoyable Game - Mafia 1, a simple game of mafia is good enough for me.
Best Game - Mafia 1 b/c of its' simplicity.

[darkclaymore]

Best Mechanic - As far as the mechanics, it was pretty good.

Which game...?

Best Mod - SJ, I suppose.
Best Player - N/A
Favorite Player - N/A
Best Flavor -
Best Scenes - Nothing really comes to mind.
Best Setup - Mafia 1, simple and effective.
Best Mechanic - Nothing comes to mind.
Most Enjoyable Game - Mafia 1, a simple game of mafia is good enough for me.
Best Game - Mafia 1 b/c of its' simplicity.

Why so empty?

[Xeras]

Best Mechanic - As far as the mechanics, it was pretty good.

Which game...?

Ah, SJ's last game.

[darkclaymore]

I wonder, are people too lazy to vote?

[Redhorse]

I wonder, are people too lazy to vote?

I plan to vote, I just have to think about the last two categories.

[lopez]

Best Mod - SJ, I suppose.
Best Player - N/A
Favorite Player - N/A
Best Flavor -
Best Scenes - Nothing really comes to mind.
Best Setup - Mafia 1, simple and effective.
Best Mechanic - Nothing comes to mind.
Most Enjoyable Game - Mafia 1, a simple game of mafia is good enough for me.
Best Game - Mafia 1 b/c of its' simplicity.

Why so empty?

B/c no one has really impressed me with their games, both literally and figuratively. The scenes and set-up are decent, no one really stands out with their play style, etc...

SJ would probably be the closest thing to the "best player", but he's been too easy to read. I would nominate him b/c I'm impressed in how he confuses everyone else when he's scum or anti-town in general.

[GameXtra]

Best Mod - Sj\

Spoiler:

Necrofantasia

.
Best Player - Xeras.
Favorite Player - DarkClaymore.

Best Flavor - Mafia 8: Imperishable.
Best Scenes - For Simplicity's Sake Mafia 2 - really enjoyed the whole evil-half against good-half scenes.
Best Setup - Mafia 8: Imperishable Night - It was simple, and yet complicated. I liked that.
Best Mechanic - For Simplicity's Sake Mafia 2 - Simple... at the beginning at least. I really enjoyed the chaos afterwards~
Most Enjoyable Game -

Spoiler:

Slice of Life Mafia\

Mafia 8: Imperishable Night. One was rly enjoyable when it started, and one was enjoyable overall.
Best Game - Mafia 8: Imperishable Night.

[Redhorse]

Best Mod - Necro (I wasn't in his game, but it seemed like he was very balanced/ organized, while still throwing in fun roles/ mechanics)
Best Player - Xeras (So good at this stuff, it scares me)
Favorite Player - DarkClaymore (he makes games twice as entertaining just by being present, lol)

Best Flavor - Mafia X: Paradigm Shift (FINAL FANTASY, YAAAAAAAAY! )
Best Scenes - Mafia XI: Inside The Head (The scenes were sooooo awesome, they had pictures, the double post thing kept tricking me, and they were hilarious to read ; just, in general, loved the scenes)
Best Setup - Mafia 8: Imperishable Night (seemed very well thought out from what I could tell)
Best Mechanic - Choose your role Mafia (choosing roles was so great ~; I liked vampko's introducing roles over time thing, too though, that was neat)
Most Enjoyable Game - Mafia XI: Inside The Head (had so much fun in that one short game)
Best Game - For Simplicity's Sake Mafia 2 (looked the most epic, with all the randomness)